Directed by Ti West and based on A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens, Ebenezer is set in early Victorian London and follows the miserly businessman Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) as he is forced through visions of the past, present, and future during a supernatural journey toward a chance at redemption on Christmas Eve.
There have been many beloved Christmas stories to have existed over the years but perhaps the most beloved among them has always been A Christmas Carol, which has had way more adaptations than can be counted in both film and television. Everyone has grown up with at least one of these many adaptations of the same story, and I myself have watched several of these different versions over the years, having enjoyed most of them. And now we have yet another adaptation, brought to us by horror director Ti West, who aimed to put his own spin on the classic tale with an ensemble cast of well-known faces, including Johnny Depp as the lead character. Even though I knew this was likely going to be the same story being done again, I was still curious to see what this adaptation had to offer given all the talent involved in it. After getting the chance to catch it at an early screening, I can honestly admit that I did end up enjoying this adaptation.
Ebenezer is a very well-made darker retelling of A Christmas Carol that manages to be emotionally compelling even if it may not be a complete reinvention of the classic story we already know. It is the exact story we have been presented many times before in other adaptations but Ti West does manage to add in his own visual style and some refreshing new layers to deepen Ebenezer’s journey creating a sincere period piece that is infused with heart, horror and despair that is great for a new generation to watch.
Ti West certainly knows how to pick some unique ensembles for his films and he chose a really solid cast that all deliver fantastic performances for their respective characters. Some were expected to be good but some also ended up exceeding expectations by offering some unique and memorable portrayals of characters from the novel. Carrying the most weight in this film in more ways than one is Johnny Depp as the titular Ebenezer Scrooge. Depp has always been known to be the master of misfit characters so playing the role of Scrooge seemed incredibly fitting and he indeed does a great job with the role balancing the characters’s notable fiendish nature with goofy charm and emotional gravitas that works surprisingly well. We have seen many actors offer their own unique portrayals of this character and Depp simply offers his own unique portrayal that ended up being magnetic and captivating throughout the character’s journey of redemption. With his strong performance and some additional layers added in by the writing, it leads to a complete redemption arc for the character that I feel delivers a bit more emotional resonance than in previous takes. The rest of the supporting cast does a brilliant job with their respective roles playing the characters from the novel perfectly on screen while giving them their own takes. Rupert Grint offers a reserved but heartfelt performance as Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s underpaid employee, while Sam Claflin offers a kind-hearted and jubilant performance as Fred, Scrooge’s nephew. Daisy Ridley is sadly underutilized as Clara, Fred’s wife, in the film but still manages to deliver a great performance that has some humorous moments of levity. Scrooge’s former love Belle ends up having a much more significant role in this adaptation compared to previous takes and she ends up getting a very emotionally moving performance by Ellie Bamber that adds a lot more emotional weight to Ebenezer’s journey. Even Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley, Scrooge’s deceased business partner, delivers an extremely memorable performance and presence in the short time he is on screen.
But by far the biggest surprise standouts of the supporting cast ended up being the three Christmas spirits: The Ghost of Christmas Past (Andrea Riseborough), the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman) and the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come (Robert Strange). Andrea Riseborough delivers an extremely haunting portrayal of the Ghost of Christmas Past giving us probably the most terrifying version of the spirit ever portrayed in any adaptation of A Christmas Carol that I have seen. She’s portrayed in such a unique way in which she offers a warm welcome but has a cold appearance representing the past literally coming to haunt Ebenezer that sends chills down your spine and makes the lessons she’s trying to teach him hit a little harder and make his once buried emotions come to light.
Tramell Tillman steals the spotlight with his booming and immense portrayal of the Ghost of Christmas Present offering yet another flawless performance to add to his resume. This version of the spirit is the one to really shake Ebenezer’s hardened ego and shows that no matter what excuses Ebenezer makes to try to justify his actions against others in the present he will always be proven wrong and be brought down to reality. And then finally we have Robert Strange playing the silent but yet still petrifying Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come. Brought to life through amazing physical acting by Strange and even more amazing practical effects, this ghost still cements himself as the most terrifying of all the spirits regardless of what adaptation he is in. He’s the one to truly set the nail in the coffin for Ebenezer to change his ways or risk setting in stone a bleak future for himself and others.
The narrative of this adaptation basically follows the exact same story of A Christmas Carol from start to end while pacing it into five staves similar to the novel. If people are expecting something entirely new or some kind of full-on reinvention of the story, they will be disappointed. But if people love the original story regardless of how many times it’s told or look at this film as a darker retelling of the classic story for a new generation then chances are people will like it since it is still the same great story being told with all the heartfelt emotional beats and important themes still fully intact but approached a little bit differently. Ti West does manage to add some new layers and additions to Ebenezer’s journey to make it more compelling and make the big emotional payoffs hit harder, which I believe he succeeded in especially given how some people in my screening were actually crying. I was even surprised to see how Scrooge’s iconic and humorous term “Humbug!” is turned into something much more heartbreaking as a result of the new additions. The themes of redemption, Greed vs. Generosity, Social Inequality and Poverty, Family and Isolation, Time and Regret and the Christmas Spirit are all still very present and executed really well in my view. Another key difference this adaptation does offer is how it leans more into the horror aspect of its ghost story elements giving some unexpected thrills alongside the heart of the original story, which is one of the benefits of having a horror director helming this adaptation.
Ti West brings his talents in horror and his unique visual style into this film through mostly magnificent technical elements that give this film a somewhat immersive gothic atmosphere and certainly makes it stand out from previous adaptations as a result. Instead of resorting to clean, modern digital cinematography, West and his crew goes for an old-timey, vintage aesthetic by deliberately matching the look, film stock, and pacing of the specific era in which the film is set in, which is something he did for his previous films like X and Pearl. Even the lighting, colors and sets bring the Victorian era back to life in a more haunting setting even when set during Christmas. Additionally the practical effects, mainly for the three main ghosts are extremely well done and really enhance the horror elements this film provides. CGI is used only lightly for some other ghosts featured in the film and while I do think they are decent, they do seem to be a little cartoonish in a few sequences. The score for the film is composed by Tyler Bates and overall it is absolutely awesome in the way it enhances the film’s various tones and emotions it goes through giving it some energy in appropriate moments.
Ebenezer is an adaptation that was clearly made to be a new take on a classic story to be introduced to a new generation that’s never seen the story before and if that was the aim of it then I’d say this film mostly succeeds on that front. It may not offer anything crazily new for some people who have seen the story multiple times over the years but I think it offers just enough to justify its existence. Whether people choose to watch this film in theaters or not is completely up to them but personally I enjoyed this film and I think it’s worth giving a go if you have any interest in it whatsoever. I’m going to give Ebenezer a B+ = 89.
You can find more of my writing on instagram, and check out my channel on YouTube!